Discussion Topic Posted for the NANOTUBE-99 Workshop:

Single-Wall Nanotubes

The equilibrium diameter of a growing single-wall nanotube, consisting of a cylinder that is terminated on one side by a cap, can be estimated for a fixed number of atoms N in the following way. Suppose that a nanotube has infinite time to find the equilibrium structure under the constraint that it be a cylinder, closed by a hemisphere at one end. The energies of importance are the strain energy in the cylinder which is proportional to 1/R, the "dangling bond" or better "edge energy" that is proportional to R, and the strain energy of the hemispherical cap that is constant. The tube can be either "long and skinny", resulting in a large strain in the cylinder, but reducing the edge energy. It may be "short and fat" with the opposite energetic consequence. The equilibrium tube radius R_eq turns out to depend only weakly on the total number of atoms, namely to be proportional to N^1/3.

These considerations have been published in

• Andreas Thess, Roland Lee, Pavel Nikolaev, Hongjie Dai, Pierre Petit, Jerome Robert, Chunhui Xu, Young Hee Lee, Seong Gon Kim, Daniel T. Colbert, Gustavo Scuseria, David Tomanek, John E. Fischer, and Richard E. Smalley, Crystalline ropes of metallic carbon nanotubes, Science 273, 483 (1996).
• Young Hee Lee, Seong Gon Kim, and David Tomanek, Catalytic growth of single-wall nanotubes: An ab initio study, Phys. Rev. Lett. 78, 2393 (1997).

Multi-Wall Nanotubes

There is no reason why an existing nanotube should not become "fatter" by acquiring additional layers that grow on a "template". A similar phenomenon may be responsible for the formation of multi-wall "bucky onions". Multi-wall nanotubes apparently require no catalyst to keep the growing edge open. There are, it is believed, "lip-lip" interactions between two or more simultaneously growing layers that somewhat passivate the growing edge, thus preventing premature oxidation. There appears to be no upper limit for the diameter of the outermost tube wall. The system would be approaching, just like fattening "bucky onions", the graphitic structure.

For literature see e.g.

• D. Tomanek, W. Zhong, and E. Krastev, Stability of Multi-Shell Fullerenes, Phys. Rev. B 48, 15461 (1993).
• Ting Guo, Pavel Nikolaev, Andrew G. Rinzler, David Tomanek, Daniel T. Colbert, and Richard E. Smalley, Self-Assembly of Tubular Fullerenes, J. Phys. Chem. 99, 10694 (1995).
• Young-Kyun Kwon, Young Hee Lee, Seong-Gon Kim, Philippe Jund, David Tomanek, and Richard E.~Smalley, Morphology and stability of growing multi-wall carbon nanotubes, Phys. Rev. Lett. 79, 2065 (1997).

URL of this document is https://nanoten.com/conf-org/NT99/puzzles/5.1.html
This document has received 00207 hits since August 9, 2020.